
After the hugely popular, award-winning Lessons in Chemistry, many people will be eager to pick up Peck & Peck, Bonnie Garmus’s new novel. And here again we have the appealing quirky writing style and empathy for her main characters, so I was soon happily ensconced in the new book.
In the very first sentence, our main character, Batter Gray, admits to having a prisoner number, and by the end of the second paragraph, we know that he was named after a dog. And in a pleasantly chatty first-person, we get Batter’s story, beginning with his upbringing and on to his eventual hiring by the publisher’s of boutique poetry journal, Peck & Peck. An only child, his twin brother having died the day he was born, Batter carries the weight of expectation of his parents, his mother a professional type designer, his dad a history teacher. But early on, Batter has discovered he has an ear for poetry.
After trying every course possible at university in order to find something he likes better that poetry – not writing it, but reading it – he makes his way to New York. Here Batter pretends to be living a life of potential, while working a bunch of low-paid jobs to pay his rent. A chance encounter finds him outside the extraordinary building of Peck & Peck, the poetry journal he has admired since his school days, and applies for a job.
I never met the dog I was named for; he died just before I was born. But I’ve always wondered if he would have preferred a different name. King, Spot. Maybe Rex. The problem with being named Batter is that it’s not really a name; it’s a word. Some assume it’s preppy, like Banks or Bennett; others insist it must have foreign roots. Still others ask (cautiously) if my dad was “really into baseball” or if my mom “enjoys baking.”
Disappointed he hasn’t stepped into an editorial position, Batter is brusquely sent to the basement to churn through the huge volumes of photocopying required – we’re in the early 1980s, before electronic copies and emailed submissions. Nobody’s very nice to him, apart from the avuncular security guard who has to fend off the constant barrage of eager and often disappointed poets desperate to have their work published. Batter soon realises that Peck & Peck is not a happy place to work for anybody.
Most of the problems arise from the managing editor, Salton, who seems to be in a perpetual rage, possibly because he hates poets, but seemingly with the financial nous to save the journal from financial ruin. This is particularly so since his twin brother Declonius served time for embezzling the journal’s funds. Yes, twins again – they pop up a lot as Peck & Peck has over several generations been managed by twin Pecks.
Meanwhile Batter finds himself caught in the crossfire between Salton and Declonius (he’s not the only one with an odd name), falls in love with someone way out of reach, and tries to keep his head above water. In fact he could have been named Battler, not Batter, as he becomes unwittingly a hero in the traditional sense trying to slay a dragon, with everything against him. Help, as it so often does, comes from unexpected quarters and the story builds to a clever finish where Mom’s typographical skills come into play.
Overall this was a very enjoyable read, although I did find my attention wavering in the middle as the plot seemed to sag a little. There are a lot of characters to keep track of, and then there are the dog stories – clearly Bonnie Garmus is very much a dog lover. Still, ten points for originality. And I did find myself appreciating poetry in a new way. There’s also plenty for the word lover as well as the typography fiend. Lots to enjoy but maybe not quite the stellar read Lessons in Chemistry was. This one’s a three-and-a-half star read from me.








